Trying to find the right Medicare option was… honestly? Overwhelming. I kept putting it off. I wasn’t excited about talking to an expert or someone who “sells insurance.” I felt kind of dumb for not knowing more, and I was dreading that I’d ask a question and just feel worse.
But I also knew in my gut that if I could find the best health insurance agency in Green Bay WI, they could help take those worries away and help me get better insurance. So I knew I had to find someone. Not just find someone with a fancy title, but find someone who would actually listen to me and help me as a person so I could feel taken care of and important. Someone who wouldn’t just rush me along before I even understood it.
I asked around a bit.
A Tip From a Friend
A friend told me to call OnMedicare Insurance Agency. They had worked with Daniel Swan and Logan Thomas, and apparently had nothing but good things to say. Still—I was skeptical. Because in the past, insurance stuff had never gone well for me. I’ve been brushed off, talked over, and made to feel like I should already have it all figured out.
But I looked them up anyway. I found their reviews, saw a little about Daniel and Lauren Swan, and something clicked. Not in a big flashy way, just a quiet little, “Hmm. This might actually be different.”
So I called.
First Contact
I talked with Annie when I called; She was kind, warm, and genuine. I told her upfront, “I’m not looking to change anything right now. Just want to talk.” And she didn’t skip a beat. She scheduled me with Logan, said he’d be happy to walk through things, no pressure. That was so nice to not feel pressured or pushed to make any quick decisions.
When I showed up, Lauren greeted me as I walked in, shook my hand and offered me some coffee or water. I didn’t have to wait, we actually started my appointment five minutes early which was nice. I also got to meet Logan before my appointment with Daniel. He was very friendly and easy to talk to. We found commonality in that we both played an instrument! When I sat in Daniel’s office he didn’t act like I was appointment number seven out of ten that day, we got to know eachother for a bit before getting into insurance talks. It was a natural pace and not rushed; slow and steady and frankly refreshing.
The Conversation
We sat down, and Daniel asked questions and I caught him up on why I was looking and what I was looking for. We talked about what I had been dealing with and what was important to me. Stuff that actually mattered.
He wasn’t just focused on getting data. He was trying to get a feel for how I think, what I care about, and where I’ve struggled with insurance in the past. It felt like I was being thoroughly listened to and understood instead of feeling judged or evaluated.
We ended up laughing about music. Turns out he played an instrument too! Also both had dogs and it was a fun little tangent. But that kind of stuff—it matters to me. It made the whole thing feel like talking with a friend instead of an interrogation!
Options Without Pressure
Once we looked through the details of my current coverage, Daniel pulled up some options and went through them with me. He first filtered through a lot of them; there were Way more than I expected. And instead of making it more confusing by showing me every one, he helped narrow it down to two plans that made the most sense based on what I’d told him earlier.
No rushing through stuff. Nothing like, “you’ve got to act now.” Thankfully. He gave me some advice and asked my thoughts; then allowed me to do what I was comfortable with.
I’d never had someone from a health insurance agency in Green Bay WI explain things so clearly, without it sounding rehearsed, robotic, or scripted. Simple language I could understand.
Questions I Thought Would Stump Him
I had done some research beforehand. I brought a few of those “gotcha” questions I’ve heard stump other agents before. Not to be difficult—just to see how deep he really understood this stuff. I asked him about an HSA I contributed in, I asked about a food benefit my friend had, I asked about getting money back on my social security check, I asked about an old retiree reimbursement program, and I even asked about Tri-Care even though I don’t have it. But my friend does and they complain that it’s confusing when you also have Medicare.
Daniel answered every single question quickly and confidently. And most importantly, in a way I actually understood. He didn’t just quote some definition or rules at me—he helped me apply them to my life.
What Happened Next
I didn’t enroll that day. We both agreed I wasn’t ready. And that was perfectly okay with him. We scheduled a future time to reconnect when I’d had a chance to think things over.
Since then, I’ve been looking forward to their annual review process. They actually meet with clients year after year, going through updates and seeing if the plan still fits. That kind of long-term help is rare.
Out of all the health insurance agencies in Green Bay WI, I don’t think I could’ve found a better fit than OnMedicare. It wasn’t just a helpful meeting—it was a real relationship starting.
If You’re Nervous, I Get It
If you’re reading this and you’re feeling unsure—if the whole Medicare maze has you frozen—I get it. Totally.
But if you can find a place like OnMedicare, where they talk with you like a person, not a number… it makes a huge difference.
They didn’t just sell me on a policy. They gave me time. They gave me confidence. They gave me space to ask every single question rattling around in my head.
And now? Now I feel like I’ve got someone in my corner.
I’m switching to them officially this year. Not just because of the savings or the benefits—though those are great—but because I trust them. And when it comes to health insurance, especially Medicare, that trust is everything.
Final Thought
You can scroll through a dozen websites. You can talk to a hundred agents. Or—you can walk into one office that just feels right. For me, that was OnMedicare. The absolute best health insurance agency in Green Bay WI.
If you’ve been holding off, maybe now’s the time to take the first step.